The funny/strange/interesting video thread...

[Dan]

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/10/18/female-israeli-soldier-uses-ninja-moves-on-threatening-crowd-of-ultra-orthodox-protesters/?utm_term=.2a98855a7100

[ADG]

She is clearly way beyond her jurisdiction and her training. She just enjoys hitting jews...

[elit]

She is clearly way beyond her jurisdiction and her training. She just enjoys hitting jews...

not much different then the ones she's hitting...

[Emkay]

not much different then the ones she's hitting...

I'm assuming you thought that was an intelligent retort without actually thinks if it has basis in reality or if it makes sense.

[Baruch]

I'm assuming you thought that was an intelligent retort without actually thinks if it has basis in reality or if it makes sense.

You think the guy that hits her from behind is doing it Lesheim Shamayim? You think the guys screaming "shiksa" are doing it lesheim shamayim?

I think they're enjoying berating another Jew.

(When I was a bachur in E"Y, I screamed "Nazi" at a rally, and enjoyed it, shame on younger me)

[whYME]

She is clearly way beyond her jurisdiction and her training. She just enjoys hitting jews...

Agreed but they deserved it.

[Emkay]

You think the guy that hits her from behind is doing it Lesheim Shamayim? You think the guys screaming "shiksa" are doing it lesheim shamayim?

Do I think that they believe they are doing it lesheim shamayim? Yes. Their own corrupted version of it.

[skyguy918]

Do I think that they believe they are doing it lesheim shamayim? Yes. Their own corrupted version of it.

That's not what he asked, but either way - how is that different from her? She also believes she's doing what's right by helping the person in the car get through.

[elit]

I'm assuming you thought that was an intelligent retort without actually thinks if it has basis in reality or if it makes sense.

actually I do. as others here have explained

[elit]

Do I think that they believe they are doing it lesheim shamayim? Yes. Their own corrupted version of it.

almost everyone thinks they're do the right thing. what relevance does that have.... they're there for the fight and she (arguably) is there for the fight. her cause is seemingly rational. their cause is seemingly completely irrational.  they're making a chillul hashem. she's not.  should I keep going? or is all that matters is that they're "frum" and she isnt

[churnbabychurn]

almost everyone thinks they're do the right thing. what relevance does that have.... they're there for the fight and she (arguably) is there for the fight. her cause is seemingly rational. their cause is seemingly completely irrational.  they're making a chillul hashem. she's not.  should I keep going? or is all that matters is that they're "frum" and she isnt

Her cause is hatred of religion people.

[elit]

Her cause is hatred of religion people.

i didnt know u know her?

[Emkay]

almost everyone thinks they're do the right thing. what relevance does that have.... they're there for the fight and she (arguably) is there for the fight. her cause is seemingly rational. their cause is seemingly completely irrational.  they're making a chillul hashem. she's not.  should I keep going? or is all that matters is that they're "frum" and she isnt

1) One initiates violence.
2) She isn't creating a chillul hashem also? Will you do yourself a favor and look into what a chillul hashem is or do you need spoon-feeding?
3)they are there for a cause and she is there for a fight. There's a nuance there that I can't force you to see.
4) Not based on them being frum and not her. I actually think the opposite is true.
5) I think they deserve to be locked up or deported but violence like that is never the answer and will never accomplish anything. And she darn well knows that.

[Emkay]

That's not what he asked.

Certainly is.

[elit]

3)they are there for a cause and she is there for a fight. There's a nuance there that I can't force you to see.
5) I think they deserve to be locked up or deported but violence like that is never the answer and will never accomplish anything. And she darn well knows that.

i didnt know u know her?

[Emkay]

Is it hard to type with your head in the sand?
I'm genuinely not sure if your just here for the argument or you honestly have this viewpoint.

[whYME]

@Emkay would you be saying the same thing if it was someone trying to bust through a BLM protest blocking a road?

[Emkay]

@Emkay would you be saying the same thing if it was someone trying to bust through a BLM protest blocking a road?

I can't honestly say for sure until that situation is in front of me, but while I think BLM protestors are misinformed and non educated in what they are actually fighting for, I do respect the protesters in Israel just as little. But violence like that is not the answer and will never be. The absence of law and order gives you Detroit and noone wants another one of those.

[elit]

[ Invalid YouTube link ]
enough said.

[Emkay]

[ Invalid YouTube link ]
enough said.

Don't link to one of the only sites less reliable than CNN in an effort to make your point.
1) Those are NOT Peleg. Not to say that Peleg wouldn't, rather these aren't.
2)I also suggest you watch that video a couple more times in a real effort to understand what exactly is happening...

I do agree that blocking an ambulance is usually unacceptable.