Jos. A Banks, Buy 1, Get 5 Free.

[dans fan]

@dans fan
gotta fix those quote tags

sorry i tried my best i am not that gr8 at this. but do read the content

[smurf]

sorry i tried my best i am not that gr8 at this. but do read the content

I get it.I think the problem is that you didn't close the end quote "[/quote   ]" try removing the spaces

[WAM]

@Dans Fan:
I'm not sure why you feel that he should ask a different rav, as opposed to simply reasking the question. Rav Leff is a posek if that makes a difference.

[dans fan]

@Dans Fan:
Rav Leff is a posek if that makes a difference.

it makes a no dif if you are going to ask a q that he would need to know what a sales rep thinks when you come into a store.

@Dans Fan:
I'm not sure why you feel that he should ask a different rav, as opposed to simply reasking the question.

if he meant that by tricking him you are stealing money i think you should ask a dif opinion bc he obliviously doesnt  understand your q. and please dont ask him or any other rov about not showing him a receipt without telling him how much the sales rep knows when he looks at your receipt.

[WAM]

it makes a no dif if you are going to ask a q that he would need to know what a sales rep thinks when you come into a store. if he meant that by tricking him you are stealing money i think you should ask a dif opinion bc he obliviously doesnt  understand your q. and please dont ask him or any other rov about not showing him a receipt without telling him how much the sales rep knows when he looks at your receipt.

Or he does understand, and that's his psak

[dans fan]

Or he does understand, and that's his psak

that would be making fun of him and although i dont know him its sounds like he is a choshuv

[dans fan]

there is no such a chalos as a return in choshen mishpat rather it can be viewed as a new mechira therefore you are the makneh and the store is the koneh therefore you are selling them a product iy simply cannot be genaivas mamon. there are other isurai deoraisa but not genaiva (wording was done bedavka to avoid goim) i can explain it be'arichus i just cant type that well so i cut it as short as possible

[WAM]

I certainly don't intend to make fun, (he's my rav) I think it's getting lost in translation (my brain - to my computer.)

[smurf]

I ordered 9 shirts during the recent sale but I wanted to return 3 of them. When I went to the store they said that for the 3 I was returning(I ordered 3 different collar types) the price listed was 0,so I would get nothing back. I was only able to exchange them for the collar that I liked.
 Now when I originally orderred my shirts 6 came out of the warehouse priced at 87.51(the price of one) for the shipment and 3 came from a local store priced at 58.34 each for a total price 175.02(the price of 2.
Now that I've exchanged them I'm left with 3 shirts and receipts to go along saying I paid 58.34 per shirt and if I return all three I should get back 175 leaving me with 6 shirts that I only paid 87.51 for. Considering that this is all based on their own return policy would that be wrong?

[smurf]

And yes when I was in the store I told them exactly how much I paid and how much I should be getting back I told them I'm returming 3 but only want credit for 1 and they wouldn't budge

[dans fan]

And yes when I was in the store I told them exactly how much I paid and how much I should be getting back I told them I'm returming 3 but only want credit for 1 and they wouldn't budge

at this point its mutar

[smurf]

at this point its mutar

I did ask this question to a dayan. He told me that once I come clean whatever extra they refund me is their mistake. I'm not saying this is the psak for everyone only it's what I was told in my case.

[dans fan]

He told me that once I come clean 

?

me is their mistake.

it has nothing to do with taos akum. the reason why its not genaiva mamon is because they are buying it from you