Women in Jewish magazines

[elit]

What is the problem with a publication being a business?

nothing but that don't pretend to be an source of or influence hashkafa and halacha

[TimT]

Far more extreme? Maybe we should look at decisions made by powerful women over the years. Lets see if there is a pattern of being extreme.

Yes. Based on letters to the editor. Based on decisions in my daughters schools made by women. (Again I don’t expect you to understand what I said)

[aygart]

nothing but that don't pretend to be an source of or influence hashkafa and halacha

You are the only one here pretending that Ami is that.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

So you read the study and saw that there was no controls?
Liar.

Instead of name calling how about pointing out the controls mentioned in the article I missed?

[aygart]

Yes. Based on letters to the editor. Based on decisions in my daughters schools made by women.

+1 some of the most extreme decisions about this topic specifically have been made by women.

[yuneeq]

Instead of name calling how about pointing out the controls mentioned in the article I missed?

The controls weren't mentioned in the article, because an article is not a study.
The study is linked but you didn't read it.

PUOSU

[@Yehuda]

From the way the poll is worded, it's clear how the OP leans.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Yes. Based on letters to the editor. Based on decisions in my daughters schools made by women.

If you keep proving my points I won't have anything to do. So in your environment women make extreme decisions? I wonder why that is?

[ChaimMoskowitz]

The controls weren't mentioned in the article, because an article is not a study.
The study is linked but you didn't read it.

PUOSU

Actually you need to PUOSH. You claimed there was controls so link to them.
You also called me a liar. Be a man and now apologize. 

[TimT]

If you keep proving my points I won't have anything to do. So in your environment women make extreme decisions? I wonder why that is?

Because for whatever reason they feel holier being more extreme than required.
Now what point of yours am I allegedly proving ?

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Because for whatever reason they feel holier being more extreme than required.

I am not disagreeing with you. I am trying to understand why in your environment they feel that way.

[aygart]

The controls weren't mentioned in the article, because an article is not a study.
The study is linked but you didn't read it.

PUOSU

No need to be so aggressive

[aygart]

I am not disagreeing with you. I am trying to understand why in your environment they feel that way.

Because in our environment it is considered a good this to be tznius

[ChaimMoskowitz]

From the way the poll is worded, it's clear how the OP leans.

That's the purpose of a poll. To validate your point. 

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Because in our environment it is considered a good this to be tznius

I get that but why would they be fair more extreme on the subject?

[aygart]

I get that but why would they be fair more extreme on the subject?

Because it makes them feel holier.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

No need to be so aggressive

He gets that way when things don't go his way. 

[aygart]

That's the purpose of a poll. To validate your point. 

You are making a point? I thought you were trying to understand a culture you are not a part of.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Because it makes them feel holier.

Is that what they are taught growing up?

[Sport]

We can discuss anything & everything (in fact we do), but most, if not all, of these magazines have rabbonim guiding them.

Seems not to be so:

Then it’s time for them to retire

Mishpacha and Ami cater to a very wide spectrum of people, from Mizrachi to Satmar. Who should their Rabbis be?