You have still not made a coherent argument why it should not be here. You dont like comparative religion...thats not what this was. There were some serious emunah questions raised. Is that something that you're uncomfortable with? Why doesnt it belong here?
Here’s what I think would be a reasonable standard of what belongs.
“Stam Yayim, tznius, x minhag is rediculous and a corruption of the mesorah”= no good.
I don’t understand x minhag in light of y. Can someone explain?= good.
This part of the Torah/ Gemara/ rishonim doesn׳t make sense/ isn’t believable= no good
I have a problem understanding x in light of y or because it seems to defy logic etc. can someone provide sources/ explain it to me in a way that makes sense to me= good
Lubavitcher Meshichistin are Ovdei Avoda Zara and aren’t real Jews= no good
Can some explain how the lubavitcher Meshichistin reconcile x with y? = good
The x Jews think they have the answers but they are hypocrites because they talk in shul= no good
I have a hard time understanding how Jews who believe in hashem talk in shul= good
Etc. etc.
Does that sound like a reasonable standard for the forums?