So.....after numerous Sm's and numerous calls to CS - and getting shot down each and every time, one nice CS lady said she'd escalate it to her superiors.
Today both my wife and I (who made the same mistake and re-applied for the CO card with our old FF number) received letters in the mail.
My wife's letter stated - once again - that since she took advantage of this offer in the past etc., she isn't eligible for any sign-up points whatsoever.
Yet, MY letter stated that I should be getting 30k miles + 20k for getting matched!
Now for the two strange things.
1 - Both our letters were signed by the same woman! How is it that she (accurately) realized that my wife already had this card, yet didn't realize that about me?
2 - I checked my account and only the bonus 20k points posted and not the base 30k. Even if the 30k will get posted soon (I'm hoping), it's still odd that the 20k got posted before the 30k.