Also
What is the best Food in Jerusalem?
(Good Hashgachot Only)
Top 3 Dairy in Jerusalem?
Top 3 Meat in Jerusalem?
This is tough. I’ll answer based on my experiences.
Dairy -
Rimon, Lucianna & greggs, in no specific order. חבה in the shuk is great I’ve eaten from their full menu once otherwise got their breakfast menu, but def goes into top 3 just not sure which of those 3 classics I’d take out. I’ve heard great things about ahavat hayam but I’ve never been there. Random mentions - happy fish in mamilla is now rabbanut mehadrin iinm, fresh in mamilla & tahana rishona are pretty good & pizza fiore in tahana rishona was also good. Hasandak in the shuk good basics at decent prices.
Meat -
Lehem basar - great food but I’ve gotten bored of their menu.
Red heifer - great food but expensive. Was very happy both times I was there this year.
Skyline would be everybody else’s pick in top 3 but I’ve had bad experiences there so it’s out for me & instead I’d say roza.
Random mentions - grill bar of course. Tommy’s. Hatch in the shuk craft beer & sausages - loved it.