Supreme Court Will Strike Down Roe v Wade

[CountValentine]

Don’t you understand words? Sheesh. No it means killing is allowed under certain circumstances.

So murder has evolved into killing after a member pointed it out you and it is me who doesn't understand words. 

[CountValentine]

I told you so many times. From a purely rationalistic view I take no position on that. From my religions view it is a form of murder.

Isn't your view and your religious view one in the same?
ETA: In case you don't understand that question then where does your view and your religious view differ on abortion? 

[imayid2]

Isn't your view and your religious view one in the same?

Yes. Because that is the truth. The Creator should have a voice in this no? But from a philosophical/rationale standpoint I wouldn’t necessarily be convinced of this.

[Sam 77]

Poll added

[biobook]

I did see that the focus was their case of IVF, but they seem to make claims that Judaism allows on demand according to the article.

There's a third situation where there might be a conflict, which is at about 6-7 months when certain severe fetal defects become evident, and some women choose to abort the fetus then, rather than continue to carry a nonviable fetus.  They did mention that, but I ignored it because it's not unique to IVF and we discussed that earlier. 

From synagogue affiliation, one of the women is reform, one conservative, one IDK, so their claims about Judaism may not be identical to those of Orthodox Judaism.

[CountValentine]

Poll added

You are no fun.

[imayid2]

ETA: In case you don't understand that question then where does your view and your religious view differ on abortion? 

They do not differ.

[CountValentine]

Yes.

So that was your choice. So why not just post your views instead of throwing your religion under the bus?

[imayid2]

So that was your choice. So why not just post your views instead of throwing your religion under the bus?

I have idea what you mean. Is the bus also a backup?

[CountValentine]

The Creator should have a voice in this no?

Say what? The Creator knows what is going to happen before it happens. If the Creator chooses to change anything, we have no say in the matter.

[aygart]

. 

From synagogue affiliation, one of the women is reform, one conservative, one IDK, so their claims about Judaism may not be identical to those of Orthodox Judaism.

This was basically my point.

I don't know anything about their religion.

I don't either but I do know about Judaism

I agree that there are concerns with some initial proposals  restricting abortion

[imayid2]

Say what? The Creator knows what is going to happen before it happens. If the Creator chooses to change anything, we have no say in the matter.

Are you imposing your religion on others again?

[CountValentine]

I have idea what you mean.

I ask anything, and your response is Judaism says...
That is deflecting to the religious view instead of your view. That is throwing Judaism under the bus since you don't want to own the response as your own.

Is the bus also a backup?

After you threw them under the bus, I have seen you backup and run over them again. 

[CountValentine]

Are you imposing your religion on others again?

I think this is the position of the major religions but feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
If that is not their position, then they should ignore what I have said as it does not pertain to them.

[biobook]

I agree that there are concerns with some initial proposals  restricting abortion

Yeah, I quoted you, but actually (naively) imagined that my post might answer CV's original question and shock them out of the loop, but looks like we have to wait for shkia for that.

[CountValentine]

...that my post might answer CV's original question...

In reality I have no questions. I am just having fun seeing how deep I can get @imayid2 to dig that hole he is in. 

[imayid2]

In reality I have no questions. I am just having fun seeing how deep I can get @imayid2 to dig that hole he is in. 

Aka nothing substantial to say.

[imayid2]

I think this is the position of the major religions but feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
If that is not their position, then they should ignore what I have said as it does not pertain to them.

Judaism is a major religion. So you are wrong.

[CountValentine]

Judaism is a major religion. So you are wrong.

Yes it is a major religion so show me where I went wrong.
Lets take it one at a time. Your creator does not know what is going to happen before it happens?

[imayid2]

Yes it is a major religion so show me where I went wrong.
Lets take it one at a time. Your creator does not know what is going to happen before it happens?

We are out of time. Next Friday