Which gebrokst foods would you miss?

[yungermanchik]

And for those practical reasons they are kept entirely separate in my house. Everyone eats as much Matzo as they want. When everyone is done with it, it is put away (and if needed, plastic tablecloth replaced), and then other food is served. Nothing goes back into the kitchen once it came out to the table.

Do you make separate brachos on the rest of the food? How do you deal with siliek yado min hapas?

[koplonko]

Do you make separate brachos on the rest of the food? How do you deal with siliek yado min hapas?

It's all one seuda, similar to any time you physically finish eating bread but are still eating whatever else there is.

ועכשיו שאין מסלקין השלחן אחר הסעודה קודם ברכת המזון אין לנו סילוק הפת בסתם עד ברכת המזון

כל מה שאוכלין ושותין על השלחן שאכלו עליו הפת סעודה אחת היא עם הפת ולכן נפטרים בברכותיה אע"פ שסילקו דעתם ממנה לגמרי

The minhag of the Rebbe is actually to eat a bit of matza at the end of the seuda

[yungermanchik]

It's all one seuda, similar to any time you physically finish eating bread but are still eating whatever else there is.

ועכשיו שאין מסלקין השלחן אחר הסעודה קודם ברכת המזון אין לנו סילוק הפת בסתם עד ברכת המזון

כל מה שאוכלין ושותין על השלחן שאכלו עליו הפת סעודה אחת היא עם הפת ולכן נפטרים בברכותיה אע"פ שסילקו דעתם ממנה לגמרי

The minhag of the Rebbe is actually to eat a bit of matza at the end of the seuda

This is different then regular as you are b'davka being mesalek the pas.
Also, here it wasn't even eaten at all with the pas.

[ExGingi]

This is different then regular as you are b'davka being mesalek the pas.
Also, here it wasn't even eaten at all with the pas.

אפיקומן.

[yelped]

The truth is that i don't really need any Gebrochts things. But 2 things are nice:
1) Not having to worry about crumbs is a nice +
2) Being able to make Kiddish after davening without washing is also a nice +

I have the same without eating gebrokts.

[yungermanchik]

אפיקומן.

By the Day Seudos?

[AsherO]

2) Being able to make Kiddish after davening without washing is also a nice +

Have another reviis of wine?

[WayBackMachine]

whats this gebrokst thing all about, wasn't it created when they were all eating laffas, today we are stuck with cruchy crackers + non gebrokst, one of the two would make more sense IMHO

[moko]

whats this gebrokst thing all about, wasn't it created when they were all eating laffas, today we are stuck with cruchy crackers + non gebrokst, one of the two would make more sense IMHO

well the two have nothing to do with each other. Actually gebrokts (at least the matzah/cake meal issue) has a source in the gemara/ tur. See chochmas Shlomo O"C 463:3

[AsherO]

well the two have nothing to do with each other. Actually gebrokts (at least the matzah/cake meal issue) has a source in the gemara

Isn’t his point that when the gzerah made in the Gemara was recorded they were discussing a different form of Matzah more similar to a laffah?

[imayid2]

whats this gebrokst thing all about, wasn't it created when they were all eating laffas

No

[imayid2]

Isn’t his point that when the gzerah made in the Gemara was recorded they were discussing a different form of Matzah more similar to a laffah?

Which gzeira?

[Ver hut gazugt]

whats this gebrokst thing all about, wasn't it created when they were all eating laffas, today we are stuck with cruchy crackers + non gebrokst, one of the two would make more sense IMHO

with “crackers” it’s more of an issue as there is less water and the flour sometimes does not get properly mixed. Which creates a risk if water touches the unmixed flour.

[moko]

Isn’t his point that when the gzerah made in the Gemara was recorded they were discussing a different form of Matzah more similar to a laffah?

the gemara discusses ground matzah. Do t know what form it was but there was definitely a concept of rikikei matzos bzman hatalmud.

[AsherO]

Which gzeira?

Gebroks. I used the term gzeira loosely.

[AsherO]

the gemara discusses ground matzah. Do t know what form it was but there was definitely a concept of rikikei matzos bzman hatalmud.

A concept perhaps, but what were they actually eating? Hillel’s sandwich was definitely a Laffah. You can’t quite be כרוך a cracker.

[moko]

A concept perhaps, but what were they actually eating? Hillel’s sandwich was definitely a Laffah. You can’t quite be כרוך a cracker.

they were grinding it up. Have you ever tried grinding a lafa?

[AsherO]

they were grinding it up. Have you ever tried grinding a lafa?

Bake it extra until it’s crumbly?

[moko]

Bake it extra until it’s crumbly?

and how will you do koirech? I guess toast after your done with koirech

[imayid2]

Gebroks. I used the term gzeira loosely.

Don’t think anyone understands gebroks to be a Talmudic din.