Have you tried Craft (NY style) or Anthony's (Italy style)?
As far as I can tell, they are both Rabbanut (Mehadrin).
Many, many locals don't accept that as first (or third) choice....
And a pizza emergency don't qualify
In a city that has so many
Truely "Mehadrin" options, (i.e. Eida, Rubin, landau, sheiris, kehilos....) why do so many "heimish" visitors insist on reinventing the wheel, not trusting local experts, "doing their own research"...
So you won't be able to eat in every highly rated place, or eat the breakfast buffet in the hotel you got on points, you won't go hungry, I promise!