The Tamar Epstein Saga

[Aaaron]

No.

Reportedly other letters are coming out to be mocheh the bizayon directed at R Shmuel.

Apparently it's not real, but it's the sentiment all the same.  We'll see more shortly.

[Hidden]

Lock thread?

Very interesting
They want to block a few websites because of bizayon hatorah
And then they add "if only the rabbonim would keep their word..."

[SayWhat]

No.

Reportedly other letters are coming out to be mocheh the bizayon directed at R Shmuel.

Reportedly other letters are coming out to be mocheh the bizayon directed at G-d

[churnbabychurn]

Very interesting
They want to block a few websites because of bizayon hatorah
And then they add "if only the rabbonim would keep their word..."

You mean those philly boys bashing R Feldman? They crazy

[henche]

Letter doesn't have a signature? I'm calling garbage.

[churnbabychurn]

Plus the gemara in bbm quoted has no shaychus.

Problem is that R Aharon Feldman has few talmidim in Lakewood to deal with these signs.
Oh well.

[churnbabychurn]

Wow ,

So the badatz obviously didn't listen to R Shmuel.

What happened with R Dovid? Did he look into this as R Shmuel wanted?

[Baruch]

Wow ,

So the badatz obviously didn't listen to R Shmuel.

What happened with R Dovid? Did he look into this as R Shmuel wanted?

Did you notice how there's a machlokes between you and Rav Shmuel?
He calls R Nota the "rosh hamumchim be'inyanei Gittin".
 

[churnbabychurn]

[akivak]

Very powerful last 2 lines!

[chaimmayer]

Two websites that have taken on the mitzvah Kedosha of refuting eidson.
(Disclaimer: I didn't read them but their style seems to be quite sharp.  I'm not sure if they are רוח חכמים נוחה הימנו either.)
http://elbonasheltorah.com/
https://daistorah.wordpress.com/

[churnbabychurn]

Two websites that have taken on the mitzvah Kedosha of refuting eidson.
(Disclaimer: I didn't read them but their style seems to be quite sharp.  I'm not sure if they are רוח חכמים נוחה הימנו either.)
http://elbonasheltorah.com/
https://daistorah.wordpress.com/

They treat R Aharon Feldman like a ..... Don't even want to say.

They are no better that eidinson.

[yuneeq]

Two websites that have taken on the mitzvah Kedosha of refuting eidson.
(Disclaimer: I didn't read them but their style seems to be quite sharp.  I'm not sure if they are רוח חכמים נוחה הימנו either.)
http://elbonasheltorah.com/
https://daistorah.wordpress.com/

Elbonah is incomprehensible and the dais is so completely pro-feminist that he is spewing in the same exact fashion as Eidonsohn.

[aygart]

They treat R Aharon Feldman like a ..... Don't even want to say.

They are no better that eidinson.

+1 and Eidenson is no better than them.

[chaimmayer]

But,did,you notice how Eidenson had,this,whole,rant yesterday how the "kamenetzky - greenblat camp" have no תוכן so they have to create forgeries and then it turns out he was way off and the letter from RAF is legit.

[Aaaron]

But,did,you notice how Eidenson had,this,whole,rant yesterday how the "kamenetzky - greenblat camp" have no תוכן so they have to create forgeries and then it turns out he was way off and the letter from RAF is legit.

Don't hold your breath for an apology.  At least he's entertaining to read though.  I like this from today:

"I received the following note from a major talmid chachom and posek. He is viewed in the Torah world as being Rav Feldman's clear superior in psak halacha and Torah knowledge. He has independently investigated the Kaminetsky-Greenblatt heter and has declared it worthless. This is his reaction to Rav Feldman's letter:"

We are doomed.
May the good Lord have mercy on us.
I have searched and re-searched--I am looking for the bizayon haTorah.
There was bizayon haTorah here--but he's mixed up about who perpetrated it.
And to say that bizayon haTorah in this case is worse than aishes ish---
We doomed,doomed,doomed.

Right... because someone who is "Rav Feldman's clear superior in psak halacha and Torah knowledge" would write that 

And at least name this person if you say those things.

[SayWhat]

מדברי מחאה של הגאון ר' א. י. סולובייצ'יק שליט"א
 ראש ישיבת בריסק
 נפל דבר בישראל
באמריקה התירו אשת איש לשוק רח"ל בלא גט -
זהו נבלה ממש
וחוץ מעצם הענין שאין רצוני ליכנס בזה שהוא באמת חמור מאוד
הרי אף במקום שצריך ליכנס להתיר עגונות ישבו רבותינו האחרונים שבעה נקיים עד שהוציא פסק
וגם בזה לא היה להם די והתנו ההיתר בהצטרפות עוד גדולים
וכאן עושים כאילו הוא דבר של מה בכך
ורשעים במחשך מעשיהם התירו ולא התירו

כאן בארץ ישראל כשרצו להתיר שני ממזרים הפכו את העולם
חובה גמורה על הרבנים וראשי הישיבות באמריקא לזעוק צעקה גדולה  על זה
והרי זהו אחריות עצומה על כל המשך הדורות באמריקה כי זה פתח לכל מיני רבנציקעש שיוכלו לעשות ככל העולה על רוחם
הכל בא מהקולדז וכו'
ואסור ללמוד אצל ראש הישיבה כזה וכמבואר ברמב"ם על הרב שאינו הולך בדרך טובה

[SayWhat]

To play nice or not to play nice - that is the question

[good sam]

R' Nota went to college?

[churnbabychurn]

R' Nota went to college?

He's American born no?