Starting Point Of Israel/Palestine Conflict?

[AsherO]

https://x.com/einatwilf/status/1722546123053596733

The narrative itself

[Ver hut gazugt]

Fascinating indeed! Belongs here.

I read #9 it was pretty bad.

[yelped]

Fascinating indeed! Belongs here.

This guy is off on so many levels. Ugh.

[mevinyavin]

Palestinian disasters will appear again.

Thank you @EliJelly and @AsherO . Was worth the read and I read it carefully. The writer left out only a mention that the Muslim Arabs in Israel did not identify as Palestinian for about two decades after IL was founded. Instead, they derisively called Jews "Palestinians" and made fun of the fake Palestine name. They were all saying, "Palestine is really part of Syria!" or "...part of Jordan!" depending on their political association.

[AsherO]

Fascinating indeed! Belongs here.

#9 doesn’t really bring anything new to the table and has a bunch of impossible suggestions that still don’t account for many unaddressed issues. The guy writes well but it’s way too verbose.

[ExGingi]

https://rumble.com/v3vfrsp-234202489.html

[ExGingi]

https://x.com/hahussain/status/1724070797113692375?s=20

[ExGingi]

@CountValentine remember that Israel was always the "little Satan" while the US is "the big Satan"

#TheWestIsNext

https://x.com/hahussain/status/1724174866989932930

[WayBackMachine]

[ExGingi]

Posting this here as I think this is very much at the root of the issues. The tendency to make up outrageous lies and believe their own lies and propaganda has been a common thread for more than a century.

https://x.com/yosephhaddad/status/1726259762977775675

[ExGingi]

https://x.com/VictorNakba/status/1726360779304087846?s=20

[ExGingi]

Worth translating.

https://x.com/droreydar/status/1726406008417751140

[mevinyavin]

https://x.com/VictorNakba/status/1726360779304087846?s=20

Did you know? The PLO was founded before the Palestinian people even existed? That the founders of the PLO declared that they are NOT Palestinian (only the accursed Jews are), but rather Jordanian, Egyptian or Syrian (depending on where they were in IL), and that they wanted to liberate Palestine and annex it to their favored country?

[Ralphie]

Theoretically, if some nation/country could trace themselves back to one of the 7 nations living in Israel/Canaan before the Jews got there for the first time after traveling through the desert, and if you take religion out of the equation and only look at it historically, would they have a good argument/claim to the land? I get it, I'm just asking theoretically.

[AsherO]

Theoretically, if some nation/country could trace themselves back to one of the 7 nations living in Israel/Canaan before the Jews got there for the first time after traveling through the desert, and if you take religion out of the equation and only look at it historically, would they have a good argument/claim to the land? I get it, I'm just asking theoretically.

IOW:

“Jews colonized Canaan over 3000 years ago. Unless you’re a Canaanite, GTFO!”

[aygart]

Theoretically, if some nation/country could trace themselves back to one of the 7 nations living in Israel/Canaan before the Jews got there for the first time after traveling through the desert, and if you take religion out of the equation and only look at it historically, would they have a good argument/claim to the land? I get it, I'm just asking theoretically.

Rashi says that Noach gave over that part of the land to Shem and Canaan was taking it from them in the times of Avraham Avinu.

[Ralphie]

Rashi says that Noach gave over that part of the land to Shem and Canaan was taking it from them in the times of Avraham Avinu.

So then why does the first Rashi in the Torah feel the need to say what he says?

[yelped]

So then why does the first Rashi in the Torah feel the need to say what he says?

Because people were anti semites and truth deniers back then already?

[jye]

So then why does the first Rashi in the Torah feel the need to say what he says?

See sifsei chachamim for several answers. One of them is that there were other descendants of Shem who could lay claim.

[ExGingi]