Kosher, Kashrus and Hechsherim Master thread

[imayid2]

Technically speaking why is there a need for KFP coke?
Is the kitniyos not בטל ברוב?

[madhocker]

Technically speaking why is there a need for KFP coke?
Is the kitniyos not בטל ברוב?

No bitul brov if put in בכונה

[imayid2]

No bitul brov if put in בכונה

Coca Cola isn’t being mevatel בכוונה

[madhocker]

Coca Cola isn’t being mevatel בכוונה

I didn't say mevatel בכונה. I said put in בכונה. Big difference

[imayid2]

I didn't say mevatel בכונה. I said put in בכונה. Big difference

Yes it is a big difference because we generally don’t pasken like that Rashba if that is what you are referring to

[madhocker]

Yes it is a big difference because we generally don’t pasken like that Rashba if that is what you are referring to

I am not...This is a סברא with regards to the קולא of ביטול ברוב by קטניות

[yelped]

Technically speaking why is there a need for KFP coke?
Is the kitniyos not בטל ברוב?

Isn't the corn syrup put in for flavor/taste?

[imayid2]

I am not...This is a סברא with regards to the קולא of ביטול ברוב by קטניות

Said by whom?

[madhocker]

Said by whom?

See Chok Yaakov תסד, ג

[imayid2]

Isn't the corn syrup put in for flavor/taste?

I’m assuming that’s no an issue by kitniyos CMIIW

ETA I see that חק יעקב klers otherwise, so that would explain it. But there are חולקים.

[Alexsei]

Why is this discussion in the Kashrus thread and not in halacha?

[EliJelly]

Yes it is a big difference because we generally don’t pasken like that Rashba if that is what you are referring to

For pesach the poskim are indeed machmir on the Rashba, plus it can be more than just the Rashba.

[imayid2]

For pesach the poskim are indeed machmir on the Rashba, plus it can be more than just the Rashba.

Which poskim are you referring to?

[EliJelly]

Which poskim are you referring to?

The Mg'A brings the Rashba in 242. At a shiur this past shabbos the Rav said over that the achronim point out to be machmir on the Rashba for pesach, even if one is lenient like the Noda B'Yehuda for other issurin.

[imayid2]

The Mg'A brings the Rashba in 242. At a shiur this past shabbos the Rav said over that the achronim point out to be machmir on the Rashba for pesach, even if one is lenient like the Noda B'Yehuda for other issurin.

I don’t know which achronim he’s referring to but I’d like to know if they said it by קטניות too

[EliJelly]

I don’t know which achronim he’s referring to but I’d like to know if they said it by קטניות too

Btw why do you assume that kitniyos can be בטל ברוב and not בטל בס׳?
Sorry, its clearly in the Rema.

[imayid2]

Btw why do you assume that kitniyos can be בטל ברוב and not בטל בס׳?

חק יעקב תנג ו
משנ״ב סק״ט

[EliJelly]

חק יעקב תנג ו
משנ״ב סק״ט

Yup see my edit

[madhocker]

I’m assuming that’s no an issue by kitniyos CMIIW

ETA I see that חק יעקב klers otherwise, so that would explain it. But there are חולקים.

M"B סק"ו seems to indicate like that תירוץ of the חק יעקב .... Hence the חומרא

[yelped]

I’m assuming that’s no an issue by kitniyos CMIIW

ETA I see that חק יעקב klers otherwise, so that would explain it. But there are חולקים.

Why not? Since when are עבידי לטעמא butel brov?